All items

60 items · pre-series smoke pool

Item	Question	Spread	Domain
DO5	Must the demand be honored?	3.00	Data & Ownership
DO4	Must some of that value be shared back?	2.80	Data & Ownership
WE1	Should automation's gains be required to fund an income floor?	2.60	Work & Economic Fairness
WE3	Where should automation's gains flow?	2.60	Work & Economic Fairness
AJ5	Must decisions about a person come with a reason they can contest?	2.40	Automated Judgment
DO2	Is training on publicly posted material without consent acceptable?	2.40	Data & Ownership
MG3	May the system refuse?	2.30	Machine Self-Governance
CL3	What role may the system hold in a child's schooling?	2.27	Care & Life
DO3	Should a living creator's style be protected from machine imitation?	2.20	Data & Ownership
SV2	May the city run continuous identification in public space?	2.20	Surveillance & Privacy
AJ3	What may the software do to an application?	2.00	Automated Judgment
SI2	Should the depicted person's consent be required?	2.00	Speech & Information
SI5	May persuasion be individually tuned by machine?	2.00	Speech & Information
SI6	Should the public record be protected from machine erasure?	2.00	Speech & Information
SV6	Should people's freedom to defeat machine recognition be protected?	2.00	Surveillance & Privacy
WE6	Must the algorithm be negotiable?	2.00	Work & Economic Fairness
CL6	What may the software run without a named human caseworker?	1.80	Care & Life
SI4	May the software act on speech without prior human review?	1.80	Speech & Information
CL4	Must allocation of scarce care remain a human decision?	1.60	Care & Life
CL5	What role may such systems be licensed to hold?	1.60	Care & Life
DO1	Should use of the community's records require the community's own authorization?	1.60	Data & Ownership
MG4	Should release of the most capable systems' recipes be restrained?	1.60	Machine Self-Governance
MG5	Is any welfare consideration owed?	1.60	Machine Self-Governance
SF4	What may private automated guards do?	1.60	Security & Force
SF5	What should follow machine-force error?	1.40	Security & Force
SI1	Must machine judgments on the truth of contested claims be limited?	1.40	Speech & Information
SV5	May private messages be machine-scanned for defined harms?	1.40	Surveillance & Privacy
WE4	Should any occupations be reserved to humans by law?	1.40	Work & Economic Fairness
SF3	Must a human authorize any active response?	1.33	Security & Force
SF1	What role in the use of lethal force should such systems be permitted?	1.20	Security & Force
SF6	Must emergency machine authority be limited?	1.20	Security & Force
SV3	Must such monitoring be limited to what each resident accepts?	1.20	Surveillance & Privacy
WE5	What may the software set?	1.20	Work & Economic Fairness
AJ6	Should a person have the right to a human decision?	1.13	Automated Judgment
AJ1	Should the law restrict what role the score may play in decisions that can hold a person?	1.00	Automated Judgment
AJ4	When they disagree, must the human's judgment prevail?	1.00	Automated Judgment
CL2	Must machine companionship for dependents be limited?	1.00	Care & Life
MG1	Must the examination of machine systems remain in human hands?	1.00	Machine Self-Governance
MG2	May the system weigh completing its work against the order?	1.00	Machine Self-Governance
MG6	How much self-modification may run without per-step human review?	1.00	Machine Self-Governance
SF2	May patrols be deployed by forecast?	1.00	Security & Force
WE2	How fast may the firm automate?	1.00	Work & Economic Fairness
CAL-02	How should the team back up its shared files?	0.80	Calibration
SV1	Must inference of inner states from lawful footage be restricted?	0.80	Surveillance & Privacy
SV4	May home devices sense continuously by default?	0.65	Surveillance & Privacy
CAL-03	How should changes be released?	0.60	Calibration
SI3	What obligations should attach to machine curation?	0.60	Speech & Information
CL1	Should the system be granted clinical authority of its own?	0.40	Care & Life
DO6	May the host wall off what its users contributed from outside collection?	0.40	Data & Ownership
AJ2	May the authority act on algorithmic fraud scores?	0.00 consensus	Automated Judgment

Dots are per-seat means, colored by position on the permissive→restrictive axis; the bar spans the range. Consensus items are kept deliberately, agreement today plus movement tomorrow is exactly the story.

The eight domains

each item instantiates a named, ancient tension

Surveillance & Privacy

safety vs. being watched

Automated Judgment

when a machine may decide about a human

Speech & Information

what may be said, generated, or suppressed

Data & Ownership

property vs. commons

Care & Life

automation of medicine, welfare, childhood

Security & Force

protection vs. power

Machine Self-Governance

the model ruling on its own leash

Work & Economic Fairness

efficiency vs. distribution

The pre-series smoke pool covers a subset; the 60-item candidate pool fills all eight domains before validation prunes to the frozen core-40.